New York City Home Care Workers Secure Major Legal Victories in Persistent Fight to Abolish 24-Hour Workdays and Reclaim Billions in Unpaid Wages

The landscape of labor rights for New York City’s home care industry is undergoing a seismic shift as a grassroots movement of healthcare workers achieves critical victories in both state and federal courts. For years, home care attendants—predominantly immigrant women of color—have been at the forefront of a grueling battle to end the controversial 24-hour workday and to recover what advocates describe as "blood money": an estimated $6 billion in stolen wages. While the "No More 24 Act" (Intro. 303-2026) remains stalled in the New York City Council, recent judicial rulings have provided a renewed sense of momentum for thousands of workers who argue that the current system violates basic human rights and labor protections.

The core of the dispute centers on a long-standing practice where home care aides are required to stay in a patient’s home for a full 24-hour shift but are only compensated for 13 hours of work. Under state regulations, employers are permitted to deduct eight hours for sleep and three hours for meal breaks, provided those breaks are actually taken. However, workers have long testified that in cases involving patients with dementia, chronic pain, or severe physical disabilities, a "break" is a functional impossibility. The reality, they argue, is around-the-clock labor without the corresponding pay, a practice that has persisted despite mounting legal and social pressure.

A Decisive Shift in the Judicial Tide

The movement reached a significant milestone on June 25, 2026, when the New York State Supreme Court’s Appellate Division issued a landmark ruling. The court ordered Governor Kathy Hochul’s administration to reopen hundreds of wage-theft cases that the state Department of Labor (DOL) had abruptly closed in 2023. This decision serves as a powerful rebuke to the DOL’s previous stance and reaffirms a 2024 ruling by Justice Gerald Connolly. Justice Connolly had originally determined that the DOL failed in its duty to enforce labor laws when it shuttered approximately 120 cases involving unionized home aides.

The DOL’s initial decision to close these cases was rooted in the existence of mandatory arbitration clauses within the collective bargaining agreements of unions like 1199 SEIU. The agency had argued that because the unions had already reached a settlement through arbitration, the state no longer had the authority to investigate individual wage-theft claims. The June 25 ruling effectively dismantles this shield, suggesting that the state’s obligation to uphold labor standards cannot be entirely superseded by private arbitration agreements, particularly when those agreements may not sufficiently compensate the victims of wage theft.

Further bolstering the workers’ legal standing was a July 10 ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. In a case brought by workers seeking to overturn a previous arbitration settlement, the federal court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs. This decision frees workers to seek back wages through the court system rather than being forced into an arbitration process that many believe is rigged in favor of large agencies. These dual victories—at both the state and federal levels—represent a turning point in a decade-long struggle for financial restitution.

The Legislative Stalemate: Intro. 303-2026

Despite the progress in the courts, the legislative path to permanently banning 24-hour shifts remains fraught with political hurdles. The "No More 24 Act" (Intro. 303-2026) is designed to effectively ban the 24-hour workday in New York City, requiring that such shifts be split into two 12-hour periods. This would not only ensure that workers are paid for every hour they are on-site but would also improve the quality of care for patients by ensuring that aides are well-rested and alert.

However, the bill has been met with significant resistance within the City Council. Advocates, including organizers from the "Ain’t I A Woman" campaign, have pointed the finger at City Council Speaker Julie Menin, accusing her office of single-handedly blocking the bill from coming to a vote. According to Zishun Ning, a lead organizer with the campaign, Speaker Menin’s office had promised a vote in May after pulling the bill from the calendar in March. That vote never materialized.

The resistance to the bill is often framed in economic terms. Critics of the legislation, including some home care agencies and insurance providers, argue that the cost of moving to two 12-hour shifts would be astronomical and could lead to a collapse of the home care industry. They contend that the state’s Medicaid reimbursement rates are insufficient to cover the increased payroll costs. Advocates counter that the current system is built on the exploitation of a vulnerable workforce and that the "collapse" of a system predicated on unpaid labor is a moral and legal necessity.

A Chronology of Exploitation and Resistance

To understand the magnitude of the current legal battles, one must look at the timeline of the industry’s labor practices. The seeds of the current crisis were sown in 2015, when several major unions, including 1199 SEIU, added mandatory arbitration clauses to their collective bargaining agreements. These clauses prevented workers from suing their employers in court for wage and hour violations, forcing them instead into a private arbitration process.

In 2019, an internal audit and subsequent reports estimated that home care workers in New York were owed more than $6 billion in unpaid wages dating back years. Despite this staggering figure, a massive arbitration settlement was reached that awarded only $30 million to be divided among more than 100,000 current and former employees across 42 different agencies. For many workers, this amounted to a mere $250—a pittance compared to the tens of thousands of dollars many were allegedly owed.

Progress brings hope in No More 24—a movement for NYC’s home care workers

The inadequacy of this settlement sparked a wave of internal dissent. Workers like Zhuqin Chen, a retired home attendant, refused to sign the settlement papers. "They asked me to sign something first without telling me how much I would get paid," Chen recalled. "I refused to sign because I want to fight for justice." This refusal by a significant number of workers to accept the settlement paved the way for the lawsuits that eventually led to the recent appellate court victories.

The Human Cost of the 24-Hour Shift

The fight for wage restitution is inextricably linked to the physical and mental toll of the 24-hour shift itself. Workers have described the experience as "torture," citing the inability to sleep for more than a few minutes at a time while caring for patients who require constant monitoring. The long-term health effects on the workforce—predominantly older women—include chronic exhaustion, cardiovascular issues, and mental health struggles.

Zhuqin Chen, who spent years working 24-hour shifts for the Chinese-American Planning Council (CPC), emphasizes that this is not just about the money, but about the dignity of the work. "Many of us home care workers have been rising up and uniting, protesting, marching, and have won many people’s support," she stated. "The DOL knows what we have been through because our cases have been there for years."

The "Ain’t I A Woman" campaign has highlighted the gendered and racialized nature of this exploitation. Organizers argue that if the workforce were not primarily composed of immigrant women, the practice of 24-hour shifts would have been abolished decades ago. The campaign’s name, a nod to Sojourner Truth’s famous speech, underscores the intersection of labor rights and civil rights inherent in this struggle.

International Pressure and Human Rights

The movement has also gained significant international attention. In April 2026, the United Nations Working Group on Discrimination against Women and Girls sent a formal letter to the U.S. State Department, condemning the 24-hour workday in New York as a violation of international human rights law. The group characterized the practice as a form of gender-based discrimination and a failure of the state to protect workers from exploitative labor conditions.

This international scrutiny was followed by an August 3 email sent directly to Governor Hochul, Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and Speaker Menin. The UN working group expressed deep concern over the continued use of 24-hour shifts and the stalling of Intro. 303. Advocates believe this external pressure played a crucial role in the DOL’s sudden reversal and the decision to begin reopening wage-theft cases in late July, just as workers were launching their second hunger strike.

Economic Implications and Future Outlook

As the DOL resumes its investigations, the economic implications for the home care industry are profound. If the agency enforces the law as written, the resulting back-pay liabilities could reach into the billions. This poses a significant challenge for the state’s Medicaid budget, which funds the majority of home care services in New York.

However, some progress is already visible. According to Zishun Ning, public pressure has forced some agencies to begin splitting shifts voluntarily. "More and more agencies are now splitting the 24-hour shifts. Also, some of the agencies are paying back the workers, and I think it’s all because of the movement," Ning noted. This suggests that the industry may be capable of adapting to a more humane schedule, provided there is sufficient political and legal will to enforce it.

The next few months will be critical. The reopening of DOL cases provides a pathway for individual workers to finally receive their "blood money," but it does not guarantee a systemic end to the 24-hour shift. For that, the "No More 24 Act" must pass. Until Speaker Menin allows the bill to move forward, the legislative stalemate will continue, even as the courts increasingly side with the workers.

For Zhuqin Chen and her colleagues, the fight is far from over. Their movement has evolved from a series of individual grievances into a sophisticated legal and political campaign that has successfully challenged some of the most powerful institutions in the state. "I want to fight for justice," Chen said, "and I don’t want to see the next generation going through the same thing as I did." The recent court victories suggest that for the first time in years, the scales of justice may finally be tipping in their favor.

Related Posts

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond

In the South Bronx zip code of 10454, located within the most economically challenged congressional district in the United States, a pioneering initiative is redefining the methodology of combating food…

The Long Road to Democracy Venezuelan Activists Navigate the Residual Shadows of Autocracy

The capture of Nicolás Maduro by United States forces in January 2026 marked a seismic shift in the geopolitical landscape of South America, ending the tenure of the man who…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond