European Union Navigates Complex Tax Reforms as Tax Foundation Europe Submits Key Recommendations on Omnibus Proposal

The European Union is currently grappling with a sweeping set of tax reforms, encapsulated in its ambitious Tax Omnibus proposal, designed to enhance the bloc’s economic growth and global competitiveness. On November 4, 2026, Tax Foundation Europe (TFE), a leading research and policy education organization, submitted comprehensive testimony to the European Commission, urging critical refinements to ensure the proposal achieves its objectives without unintended consequences. Martha Caziero, TFE’s Head of Policy, highlighted two principal areas requiring immediate attention: the proposed elimination of holding requirements for withholding tax exemptions under the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (PSD) and the Interest and Royalty Directive (IRD), and the need for greater clarity regarding the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD) as a minimum standard versus a framework for maximum harmonization.

Background to the Tax Omnibus Proposal

The Tax Omnibus proposal represents the European Commission’s ongoing effort to modernize and streamline the EU’s direct taxation framework. Its primary aim is to remove tax-related obstacles to cross-border investment and business operations within the single market, thereby fostering a more integrated and competitive economic environment. This initiative is part of a broader strategy to ensure the EU remains an attractive destination for investment while safeguarding Member States’ tax revenues and preventing aggressive tax planning. The proposal has generated significant discussion among Member States, particularly concerning its potential impact on national fiscal autonomy and revenue distribution. The European Commission formally launched the proposal earlier in 2026, prompting a series of public consultations to gather expert opinions and stakeholder feedback before its consideration by the Council.

Tax Foundation Europe, whose mission is to develop research and educate policymakers on tax matters impacting the EU’s economy, presented its analysis to contribute meaningfully to these ongoing discussions. TFE’s input focuses on aspects that directly affect growth and competitiveness, rather than offering a comprehensive review of the entire proposal.

Revisiting Withholding Tax Exemptions: PSD and IRD Reforms

Central to the Tax Omnibus proposal is the amendment to the PSD and IRD, which currently provide exemptions from withholding taxes on dividend, interest, and royalty payments between associated companies within the EU. These directives traditionally require a minimum shareholding threshold—10 percent for the PSD (parent company holding subsidiary shares) and 25 percent for the IRD (associated companies connected by shareholding)—to qualify for the exemption. Below these thresholds, Member States retain the freedom to levy withholding taxes on cross-border payments. The proposed amendment seeks to abolish these thresholds entirely, extending the exemption to so-called "portfolio investments" (i.e., shareholdings below 10 percent and 25 percent).

The Rationale for Abolishing Thresholds

From TFE’s perspective, the abolition of these thresholds is a welcome step towards enhancing the free movement of capital within the EU. The current system often leads to definitive double or even triple taxation, creating significant disincentives for cross-border investment. For instance, dividend income can be taxed at three levels: first, as corporate income in the distributing company’s state; second, via withholding tax by the distributing company’s state on the dividend payment; and third, as corporate income in the receiving company’s state of residence. While EU law and Double Tax Conventions (DTCs) attempt to mitigate these issues, they often fall short, particularly in complex triangular or multi-country scenarios, or due to divergent interpretations of treaty terms.

Moreover, the administrative burden associated with claiming exemptions or refunds for over-withheld taxes disproportionately affects smaller investments. TFE’s testimony cites research indicating a negative correlation between high recovery costs for withheld taxes and investment decisions. The time lags and administrative complexities involved in claiming refunds deter cross-border portfolio investments, hindering the functioning of the internal market.

TFE further argues that the distinction between "direct" (controlling) and "portfolio" investments for withholding tax exemptions is not fundamentally justified. The OECD Model Convention, for example, grants more beneficial treatment to direct holdings, but the rationale of avoiding recurrent taxation and facilitating international investment applies equally to portfolio investments. A dividend or interest payment is subject to multiple layers of taxation regardless of the percentage of investment. While the exemption for direct holdings aims to ensure neutrality between establishing a subsidiary and operating through a permanent establishment (PE), extending this exemption to portfolio investments would not undermine this goal; rather, it would ensure all dividend payments are treated equally, while also alleviating the double taxation burden on portfolio investors.

Member State Concerns and TFE’s Solutions

Despite these benefits, Member States have voiced significant concerns, primarily regarding the potential for asymmetrical fiscal effects. Abolishing the thresholds would shift taxing rights, particularly for interest and royalties, predominantly towards residence Member States. Capital-importing countries, which currently levy withholding taxes at source, stand to lose revenue, while capital-exporting countries, which typically provide credit for taxes withheld abroad, would experience positive revenue impacts. Eurostat’s balance of payments statistics for 2026 indicate that countries like Luxembourg, France, and the Netherlands are net importers of portfolio investments, potentially facing revenue shortfalls, whereas Germany and Italy are net exporters, likely benefiting from reduced credit obligations.

To mitigate this uneven revenue impact, Tax Foundation Europe proposes two innovative solutions:

  1. A Revenue-Sharing Clause: Inspired by the now-repealed Savings Directive, TFE suggests inserting a revenue-sharing mechanism into the directives. Under this clause, capital-exporting countries that gain from no longer needing to credit foreign withholding taxes would transfer all or part of that gain to capital-importing countries experiencing revenue losses. To simplify implementation, a statistical formula could be used, approximating annual returns on aggregate equity and debt assets held in other Member States. For dividends, TFE proposes a rate of 2.34 percent, derived from the average EU corporate income tax rate multiplied by the average taxable share of domestic dividends. For interest and royalties, a 6 percent rate is suggested, based on average DTC-based withholding tax rates among EU Member States. These rates and classifications could be updated annually.
  2. An EU Own Resource: An alternative, with a clearer EU-wide distributional rationale, would be to treat these amounts as an EU own resource. Capital-exporting countries would transfer amounts corresponding to the foreign tax credits they previously granted to the EU budget, making the operation broadly revenue-neutral for them compared to the status quo. Capital-importing countries, while not receiving a direct fiscal transfer, would benefit collectively from the financing of common EU expenditures, contributing to an equitable distribution of the fiscal burden.

Clarifying ATAD: Minimum Standard or Maximum Harmonization?

The second major area of TFE’s testimony addresses the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD), which was initially designed as a minimum standard for protecting Member States’ tax bases, allowing them to implement more stringent measures if desired. However, TFE observes that several provisions within the Tax Omnibus proposal blur this distinction, particularly concerning Controlled Foreign Company (CFC) rules and interest limitation rules.

The current wording in the proposal, such as "the Member States shall" for certain exclusions from CFC rules, creates ambiguity. It conflicts with ATAD Article 3’s general statement that the Directive sets a minimum standard, and with other proposed CFC rules that explicitly prohibit divergence only from specific provisions. This lack of clarity leads to legal uncertainty for both Member States and taxpayers, undermining the harmonization efforts that justify the directive under Article 115 TFEU.

TFE recommends amending ATAD Article 3 to state that the Directive establishes a minimum standard "unless otherwise provided." This would allow the minimum-standard rule to apply by default, while provisions using explicit mandatory language would operate as maximum harmonization. For the CFC provision, TFE suggests either deleting the new paragraph eight (the express prohibition) and consistently using "shall" for mandatory and "may" for optional provisions, or retaining paragraph eight and extending its express prohibition to other relevant paragraphs to ensure clear mandatory application.

R&D Full Expensing: Defining Equivalence

The proposal also introduces an R&D full expensing provision as a minimum harmonization measure, allowing Member States to maintain or introduce more favorable domestic incentives. This raises a crucial question for Member States: how to assess the "equivalence" of their existing R&D incentives compared to the proposal’s full expensing rule. The R&D full expensing provision requires Member States to allow taxpayers to deduct qualifying R&D capital expenditure in the year of acquisition or within four years.

TFE explains that full expensing is beneficial because it allows immediate deduction of investment costs, preventing inflation and the time value of money from eroding the real value of deductions over time, which typically occurs with traditional depreciation schedules. TFE suggests that one clear criterion for equivalence could be the net present value of deductions allowed. If a domestic rule enables taxpayers to recover at least the real value of their capital investment, it should be considered equivalent. Examples include neutral cost recovery rules, which adjust depreciation for inflation and a notional return on capital, or certain super deductions.

However, TFE cautions that if the proposal merely establishes a minimum floor without clear guidance on equivalence, it risks creating a variety of (economically equivalent) incentives that may not genuinely remove obstacles to the internal market, or address differing tax liabilities for R&D businesses across Member States. TFE therefore urges clarification of the R&D full expensing provision’s scope and the specific criteria for alternative equivalent regimes.

Broader Implications and Outlook

The Tax Omnibus proposal, as analyzed by Tax Foundation Europe, is a critical juncture for the EU’s tax policy. Successfully navigating the complexities of withholding tax exemptions and ATAD harmonization is paramount for fostering a truly integrated and competitive internal market. The proposed changes, if implemented effectively, could significantly reduce administrative burdens, eliminate definitive double taxation, and encourage cross-border investment. However, failure to address the potential for asymmetrical revenue impacts and the ambiguities in harmonization standards could lead to new challenges, including fiscal instability for some Member States and continued legal uncertainty for businesses.

The Council’s ongoing discussions will be crucial in shaping the final form of these legislative changes. The recommendations put forth by Tax Foundation Europe underscore the need for a balanced approach: one that prioritizes the objectives of growth and competitiveness while ensuring fiscal fairness and clarity across the Union. The decisions made in the coming months will profoundly influence the EU’s economic trajectory and its standing as a global economic power.

Related Posts

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

When individuals and entities sell capital assets, such as real estate, corporate stock, or other investments, the net earnings derived from these transactions, known as capital gains, are typically subject…

Digital Services Taxes Under Scrutiny: Economic Analysis Reveals Detrimental Impacts on European Economies and Global Trade

Digital Services Taxes (DSTs), levies on the gross revenues earned by large companies from specific digital activities, are increasingly under the microscope for their economic inefficiencies and distortive effects. These…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond