The landscape of American philanthropy is undergoing a fundamental transformation as traditional top-down funding models are increasingly scrutinized for their inability to reach the most marginalized communities. At the forefront of this shift is NEO Philanthropy, which recently concluded a significant national participatory grantmaking (PGM) pilot program for the Economic Mobility and Opportunity Fund. Supported by an $8.6 million investment from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, this initiative sought to challenge long-standing assumptions about how capital is distributed and who is qualified to make those decisions. By transferring power from institutional gatekeepers to an advisory committee of individuals with lived experience and professional expertise, the pilot program has provided a blueprint for a more equitable and effective approach to social investment.
Participatory grantmaking is defined as a practice that cedes decision-making power to the very people a fund is intended to serve. While the concept has existed in various forms for decades, it remains an underutilized strategy in mainstream philanthropy. The NEO Philanthropy pilot represents a rigorous attempt to institutionalize this practice within the context of economic mobility—a sector where "expert-led" interventions have frequently failed to produce sustainable upward movement for low-income populations.
The Evolution of Participatory Grantmaking and the Pilot Timeline
The journey toward this national pilot did not occur in a vacuum. Over the past five years, the Strategic Partnership Programs team at NEO Philanthropy has been refining its approach to pooled funds and donor-advised initiatives. Since 2019, the organization has facilitated the distribution of more than $10 million through various participatory frameworks, focusing on areas such as post-secondary education for underserved students and community-led economic development.
The specific timeline for the Economic Mobility and Opportunity Fund pilot began with the announcement of the $8.6 million infusion from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. This capital was earmarked specifically for research and data initiatives aimed at identifying and scaling solutions for upward mobility in the United States. Following the initial funding, NEO Philanthropy spent the first quarter of the project cycle assembling a diverse advisory committee. Unlike traditional boards, this committee was composed of individuals who possessed both technical knowledge of economic systems and personal, "lived experience" with the barriers to economic stability.
Throughout the subsequent twelve months, the committee moved through several distinct phases: the design of a Request for Proposals (RFP), the establishment of evaluation criteria, the review of applicant pools, and the final deliberation on resource allocation. This chronological progression was marked by a series of "unlearning" exercises, where both the institutional staff and the community advisors had to deconstruct their preconceived notions of philanthropic authority.
The Psychological and Structural Weight of Power Sharing
One of the most significant findings from the NEO Philanthropy pilot was that the transfer of power is not merely a procedural change but an emotional and psychological transition. For many years, the philanthropic sector has operated under the assumption that inviting community members to the table is an inherently and immediately empowering act. However, the pilot revealed a more complex reality: the "weight of the checkbook."
Advisory committee members often experienced a profound sense of responsibility and, at times, guilt. Because many of the advisors had deep ties to the communities they were representing, the stakes of the funding decisions felt personal. When the demand for resources inevitably outweighed the available funds, committee members faced the difficult task of rejecting organizations that they knew were doing vital work. This led to a recurring question among the participants: "Why me?"
Facilitators at NEO Philanthropy noted that this discomfort stemmed from the normalization of institutional philanthropy as the "rightful" arbiter of resources. To address this, the pilot incorporated "facilitation as care," a method that allowed advisors to process the emotional burden of decision-making. The goal was to shift the internal narrative from "Who am I to decide?" to "How can my proximity and expertise lead to a more informed decision than a distant institution could make?" This transition is critical for the sustainability of PGM, as it acknowledges that community leaders are not just "guests" in the process but are the most qualified experts to steward resources toward impactful solutions.
Data-Driven Analysis: The Impact of Traditional vs. Participatory Rubrics
To ensure rigor, the pilot utilized scoring rubrics similar to those found in traditional grantmaking. However, the application of these rubrics differed significantly. In a standard philanthropic setting, a rubric often serves as the final word on an applicant’s viability, prioritizing those who can best articulate their goals in the specific academic or professional language favored by foundations.
The NEO pilot found that relying solely on scores often reproduced the very biases the program sought to eliminate. Organizations with professional grant writers and high administrative capacity naturally scored higher on traditional metrics, while grassroots organizations with deep community trust but fewer formal resources often lagged behind.

In response, the advisory committee used the rubric as a starting point for deliberation rather than the end. By integrating contextual and community knowledge into the scoring process, the committee was able to identify "high-potential" organizations that might have been overlooked in a standard review. This "expanded rigor" allowed for a more holistic evaluation of an organization’s impact, looking beyond the polish of a written application to the actual efficacy of its community interventions.
The Paradox of Accessibility: Open vs. Targeted RFPs
A central debate during the design phase of the pilot concerned the structure of the Request for Proposals (RFP). Initially, there was a strong consensus within the advisory committee that an "open" RFP—one where any organization meeting basic criteria could apply—was the most equitable approach. The logic was that broad access would naturally lead to a more diverse and equitable outcome.
However, the pilot’s findings challenged this assumption. An open RFP often creates an "accessibility paradox." While it allows everyone to apply, it disproportionately favors organizations that have the "human capital" to navigate complex application processes. Smaller, underfunded nonprofits often lack the time and staff to compete in a massive, open pool, effectively barring them from the opportunity despite the theoretical "openness" of the process.
Conversely, a "targeted" or "closed" RFP allows a funder to proactively invite organizations that are known to be doing effective work but are disconnected from the traditional philanthropic ecosystem. While this limits the initial pool, it can reduce the "burden of the ask" on small nonprofits and increase the likelihood that funding reaches the most grassroots levels.
The NEO Philanthropy team concluded that there is no single "correct" way to design an RFP. Instead, the choice must be guided by the specific goals of the fund. For this pilot, the committee learned to ask: "What are we trying to make more equitable, for whom, and what design choice gets us closer to that outcome?" This nuanced approach to RFP design is a major departure from the "one-size-fits-all" mentality that dominates much of the sector.
Broader Implications for the Philanthropic Sector
The results of the NEO Philanthropy pilot arrive at a time when the broader philanthropic sector is grappling with its role in perpetuating systemic inequality. According to data from the Council on Foundations, while many organizations have pledged to increase their focus on racial and economic equity, the actual mechanisms of grantmaking have remained largely unchanged. Most funding still flows to large, well-established nonprofits, often led by individuals who do not share the lived experience of the communities they serve.
The $8.6 million investment from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation into this PGM pilot serves as a signal to other major institutional donors. It suggests that the value of participatory grantmaking lies not just in the "feel-good" aspect of community involvement, but in the superior quality of the resulting investments. When decisions are informed by those with "proximity" to the problem, the solutions are more likely to be culturally relevant, sustainable, and effective.
Industry analysts suggest that the success of such pilots could lead to a "democratization of data." In the context of economic mobility, this means that "data" is no longer just a collection of spreadsheets and academic studies, but includes the lived realities and qualitative insights of community members. By elevating this form of knowledge to the center of the decision-making process, philanthropy can move from being a "benefactor" to being a true partner in social change.
Conclusion: The Future of Participatory Practice
As NEO Philanthropy continues to share the learnings from its Economic Mobility and Opportunity Fund pilot, the organization emphasizes that participatory grantmaking is not a "service" to be offered, but a practice to be lived. The pilot has demonstrated that shifting power is a difficult, messy, and deeply rewarding process that requires institutions to be willing to "look in the mirror" and confront their own biases.
The long-term impact of this initiative will be measured not just by the millions of dollars distributed, but by the shifts in mindset among the participants. For the advisory committee, the experience provided a platform to exercise their expertise in a way that directly influenced the flow of capital. For the funders, it provided a rare opportunity to step back and allow community wisdom to lead the way.
In an era where economic mobility remains one of the most pressing challenges in the United States, the lessons from the NEO Philanthropy pilot suggest that the answers may not lie in the boardrooms of the nation’s largest foundations, but in the hands of the people who have navigated the systems themselves. By centering community expertise, philanthropy can finally begin to fulfill its promise of creating a more just and equitable society.








