The IRS Issues Guidance on AI-Assisted Tax Preparation and Billing Practices

The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into tax preparation and professional services presents both unprecedented opportunities for efficiency and significant challenges regarding ethical billing and professional responsibility. A pivotal alert from the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR), Alert 2026-19, dated June 24, 2026, directly addresses these emerging issues, clarifying the standards practitioners must uphold when utilizing AI-powered tools. The core message from the OPR is unequivocal: AI is a tool to augment professional judgment, not replace it, and billing practices must accurately reflect time actually spent and services rendered.

Navigating the New Landscape: AI and Professional Due Diligence

The IRS alert underscores a fundamental principle enshrined in Circular 230, Section 10.22, which mandates due diligence in the preparation, approval, and filing of tax returns and other documents submitted to the Treasury, as well as in representations made to clients. When generative AI tools are employed in the workflow, practitioners are explicitly required to conduct a thorough review of the documents and the language produced by these technologies. The OPR’s guidance emphasizes that practitioners cannot rely solely on the output of AI. Instead, the text generated by AI should be treated as a preliminary draft, subject to rigorous scrutiny by the qualified professional. This means verifying facts, confirming the accuracy of citations, and double-checking calculations before any work product is finalized and submitted to a client or a tax authority.

The alert clearly delineates AI’s role as an assistive technology, a valuable aid that can expedite research and drafting processes. However, it firmly establishes that AI is not a substitute for the nuanced judgment, critical thinking, and ethical considerations that are the hallmark of professional expertise. The ultimate decision-making authority and accountability remain with the human practitioner. This distinction is crucial in maintaining the integrity of the tax profession and ensuring client trust.

The Ethics of Billing in the Age of AI

Beyond the technical aspects of AI-assisted preparation, IRS Alert 2026-19 also tackles the critical issue of billing practices, specifically referencing Circular 230, Section 10.27(a). This section prohibits practitioners from charging unconscionable fees for services rendered in matters before the IRS. The OPR highlights that while AI tools can indeed shorten the time required for research and drafting, this efficiency must not be exploited to inflate billing.

Charging for manual labor that was not performed, billing for time that was not actually spent, or engaging in double billing for tasks that were facilitated by AI can all constitute violations of Section 10.27. The alert suggests that the OPR will examine billing patterns for any noticeable irregularities across multiple clients or significant discrepancies in billing amounts as indicators of potential violations. The underlying principle is that clients should benefit from the cost savings realized through technological advancements.

The IRS strongly advises that any cost savings derived from the use of AI should be openly communicated and passed on to clients. This can be achieved through transparent disclosures, either in general or specific terms, detailing the AI activities undertaken and fairly crediting any resulting cost reductions to the client’s account. While hourly billing remains a permissible method for firms to employ, the crucial caveat is that invoices must accurately reflect the time that was genuinely invested in the client’s matter. Invoices should not include charges for minutes or hours that the file did not necessitate due to AI efficiencies.

Shifting Billing Models: A Trend Towards Value and Fixed Pricing

The professional services landscape is already undergoing a significant transformation in billing methodologies, driven by the adoption of new technologies. A joint news release from the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) and the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA), issued on September 10, 2025, from New York, detailed a discernible trend. This trend indicates a gradual but steady increase in the adoption of value-based and fixed pricing models, occurring concurrently with a decline in traditional hourly billing. This shift is directly attributed to firms embracing technological advancements and expanding their service offerings beyond mere time-based execution.

These insights are further substantiated by the 2025 MAP (Management of an Accounting Practice) executive summary, compiled by the AICPA Private Companies Practice Section and CPA.com. The survey, conducted between May 5 and July 18, 2025, collected data from firms regarding their fiscal year 2024 operations. Out of over 1,400 firms that responded to some questions, 1,073 completed the entire survey.

The survey results reveal that 63% of responding firms still utilize hourly billing. However, other pricing models are gaining traction: 40% of firms employ a per-tax-form fee, 30% are using value billing (an increase of five percentage points since 2022), and 29% have adopted fixed pricing (up four percentage points). It is important to note that firms can utilize multiple billing methods, which explains why the percentages for these four categories sum to more than 100%. These figures represent the prevalence of each method, not their share of overall revenue.

The MAP executive summary explicitly states that firms are moving away from hourly billing towards value-based engagements. This strategic shift aims to better reflect the expertise, insights, and tangible outcomes delivered to clients, rather than solely focusing on the hours logged. The report suggests that this transition is aligned with evolving client expectations, the substantial investments firms are making in technology, and the increasing value and specialized nature of the services being provided.

Interestingly, the same summary highlights a challenge many firms face: 40% of respondents indicated they had not yet developed effective methods for tracking the efficiencies gained from technological advancements. Furthermore, 61% reported increasing their fees to account for higher technology investments. This presents a complex pricing conundrum for firms: how to price work that has become more efficient due to AI, when the firm struggles to quantify those efficiencies. It is important to contextualize these percentages; they reflect the responses of MAP survey participants and are not a comprehensive billing study across all professional service sectors like law firms, agencies, or design practices.

Defining Deliverables: Contingent Fees and Stated Prices

The IRS alert and the evolving billing practices also bring to the forefront the distinction between different fee structures, particularly concerning contingent fees and stated prices for services. Under Rule ET § 1.510.001 of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, a contingent fee is defined as a fee that is contingent upon the attainment of a specified finding or result, or whose amount is dependent on such a finding or result.

The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct strictly prohibits members from preparing an original or amended tax return, or a claim for a refund, for a contingent fee for any client. This prohibition extends to situations where a member or their firm performs an audit or review of a financial statement, a compilation under specific circumstances, or an examination of prospective financial information for a client.

While the rule restricts contingent fees tied to specific outcomes, it acknowledges that fees may legitimately vary based on the complexity of the services rendered. A fee structure where the price fluctuates directly with the tax result, however, is the arrangement that the rule explicitly curtails. The alert clarifies that labeling such a fee as "value pricing" does not exempt it from the purview of this rule. This interpretation is based on the plain language of the rule and should not be construed as specific advice for any particular engagement.

Moving Forward: Practical Implications for Practitioners

The guidance issued by the IRS OPR and the observed trends in billing methodologies necessitate a proactive approach from accounting and tax professionals. As a practical matter, firms are advised to meticulously document the billing methods they currently employ. When using AI-generated drafts, the practitioner responsible for signing off on the final work product must remain the central figure in the review process. Any invoices submitted must accurately reflect the actual time spent on the engagement, meticulously removing any minutes or hours saved through AI efficiencies.

For firms that opt to state a price for a tax return or other deliverable, this stated price should be determined independently of the final tax outcome for the client. This ensures compliance with ethical guidelines that prohibit fees contingent on specific tax results. A fixed fee for a service offers a clear and transparent alternative to hourly billing, effectively circumventing the issue of invoicing for time not actually spent. The OPR’s alert does not mandate a specific billing structure but reiterates the fundamental requirement that firms selling their time must accurately account for the time they have genuinely invested.

The implications of these guidelines are far-reaching. Firms that embrace AI without a corresponding adjustment in their ethical and billing practices risk regulatory scrutiny and damage to their professional reputation. Conversely, those that thoughtfully integrate AI while upholding principles of transparency, due diligence, and fair billing can leverage these tools to enhance client service, improve efficiency, and ultimately strengthen their competitive position in the evolving professional services market. The future of tax and accounting practice will likely be characterized by a hybrid approach, where cutting-edge technology is harnessed to support, not supplant, the indispensable human element of professional expertise and ethical conduct.

About the Author:

Steven de la Fe, CPA, is a co-founder of Precision AI OS, a firm specializing in AI solutions for the accounting industry. With two decades of experience in tax and accounting, including a seven-year tenure at PwC, de la Fe brings a wealth of practical knowledge and foresight to the discussion of technology’s impact on professional services. His expertise is particularly relevant in navigating the complex intersection of AI, professional responsibility, and business operations.

Related Posts

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Expensify, a prominent player in expense management, corporate card, travel, and payments solutions, has officially unveiled the Expensify Experts Council, an exclusive, invitation-only advisory body. This strategic initiative brings together…

Doeren Mayhew Acquires LPT CPAs + Advisors, Significantly Expanding Texas Footprint and National Reach

Top 50 accounting firm Doeren Mayhew has announced its strategic acquisition of LPT CPAs + Advisors, marking a significant expansion into the Amarillo market and solidifying its presence in Texas…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Intricacies of Capital Gains Taxation: Examining the Impact of Non-Indexed Basis and Double Taxation

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

The Unseen Barrier: How Widespread Misconceptions About Cost Leave Millions of Americans Underinsured

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

BlackLine Achieves AIUC-1 Certification, Setting New Standard for Agentic Financial Operations Platforms

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Expensify Launches Expert Council to Shape Future of Financial Technology

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Colorado Supreme Court Settlement in Netflix Case Clarifies Retroactive Taxation of Digital Streaming Services

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond

Transforming Food Systems Through Community Engagement: The LEAF Program’s Impact in the South Bronx and Beyond