Retail groups have launched a new legal offensive, filing two federal lawsuits aimed at reinstating Illinois’ efforts to ban specific credit card interchange fees, commonly known as "swipe fees." The suits, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, challenge rules established by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). These regulatory actions were instrumental in a federal judge’s decision to permanently block the Illinois law earlier this year.
This latest legal maneuver marks a significant escalation in a protracted battle spanning several years between the retail sector, which seeks to reduce these transaction costs, and financial institutions, which have staunchly defended them. The core of the dispute lies in the fees banks and credit card companies charge merchants on every credit card transaction. These fees are calculated on the total purchase amount, including sales taxes and any tips. The Illinois law, enacted by the General Assembly and signed by Governor JB Pritzker, sought to provide financial relief to retailers by prohibiting these fees from being applied to the tax or tip portions of a customer’s bill.
The plaintiffs in these new lawsuits include a coalition of prominent national and state retail organizations. Among them are the Illinois Retail Merchants Association (IRMA), which has been a leading advocate for the legislation, the National Retail Federation (NRF), and the Illinois Restaurant Association. Their collective aim is to circumvent the federal regulatory obstacles that have thus far thwarted the state’s initiative.
Neither the OCC, the NCUA, nor the Illinois Attorney General’s office, led by Kwame Raoul, immediately provided comment when contacted by the Chicago Tribune. However, the continued legal uncertainty surrounding the swipe fee ban has tangible consequences for businesses and consumers alike.
"As litigation continues, swipe fees continue to cost retailers and therefore consumers," stated Rob Karr, President and CEO of the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, in a phone interview. "It undermines retailers’ ability to keep prices for consumers down." This sentiment underscores the retail industry’s long-held contention that swipe fees are an undue burden that ultimately gets passed on to the end consumer in the form of higher prices.
A Timeline of the Swipe Fee Fight
The conflict over swipe fees in Illinois is not new. Financial institutions have actively opposed the state’s ban for over two years, engaging in a multi-front battle that has unfolded in the statehouse, federal courts, public relations campaigns, and at the federal level in Washington D.C.
The legislative journey began with the passage of the Illinois law, intended to curb what retailers perceived as excessive swipe fees. In February, Chief Judge Virginia M. Kendall of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois initially ruled that key provisions of the law could take effect, a decision that was celebrated by retailers. This ruling provided a temporary victory for the retail industry, signaling a potential shift in the landscape of credit card transaction costs.
However, the momentum shifted in April when federal regulators, specifically the OCC and NCUA, intervened by issuing rules that effectively favored financial institutions and challenged the state law’s legality. This federal action led to a significant setback for retailers. Consequently, in early June, Judge Kendall issued a permanent injunction, halting the enforcement of the law for most types of financial institutions that would have been impacted.
Adding another layer of complexity, almost concurrently with the permanent injunction, the Illinois General Assembly voted to delay the implementation of the act until July 2027. This delay, while seemingly a concession, has been viewed by some as an attempt to buy time and potentially influence future legal or regulatory outcomes.
Both sides have since appealed Judge Kendall’s permanent injunction. The appeals are currently before the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, with oral arguments anticipated by the end of February, according to a recent court order. This ongoing appellate process means the ultimate fate of the Illinois swipe fee ban remains undecided.
The Economic Stakes of Swipe Fees
Swipe fees, officially known as interchange fees, are a fundamental component of the credit card payment system. Merchants pay these fees to payment card networks and issuing banks for each transaction processed. These fees are designed to cover various costs, including fraud prevention, payment processing infrastructure, and rewards programs offered to cardholders.
Data from the Nilson Report, a respected industry publication, indicates that U.S. merchants paid an estimated $160.7 billion in credit card processing fees in 2023. While these figures encompass all types of fees, interchange fees constitute the largest portion. Retailers argue that these fees are disproportionately high, especially when calculated on sales taxes and tips, which do not directly contribute to the merchant’s revenue but increase the total transaction value on which the fee is based.
For example, a $100 purchase with a $10 tip and $8 sales tax would result in a $118 transaction. If the interchange fee is 2%, the merchant pays $2.36 in fees. Retailers contend that the portion of the fee applied to the $18 tax and tip is essentially a fee on money that does not go to the retailer’s bottom line. The Illinois law aimed to eliminate this specific practice, projecting potential annual savings for Illinois businesses in the tens of millions of dollars.
Arguments from Both Sides
Financial institutions and their representatives have consistently argued that eliminating swipe fees, or altering their structure as proposed by Illinois, could introduce significant "chaos" into the established payment system. They contend that these fees are essential for maintaining the security, reliability, and innovation of the U.S. payment infrastructure, which underpins a substantial portion of the nation’s economy. They also argue that changes could necessitate adjustments to consumer rewards programs and potentially lead to increased costs or reduced benefits for cardholders, or even a shift towards less secure payment methods.
Conversely, retailers maintain that the credit card law would lead to lower costs for both businesses and consumers. They dismiss arguments about widespread inconvenience as exaggerated, asserting that the payment processing system is robust enough to adapt to such changes without disruption. The Illinois Retail Merchants Association has emphasized that swipe fees are a significant operating expense, particularly for small businesses operating on thin margins. They argue that these fees act as a hidden tax on commerce, ultimately hindering economic growth and consumer spending power.
The Impact of Federal Regulatory Action
The intervention of federal regulators like the OCC and NCUA has been a critical turning point in the legal battle. These agencies, which oversee federal banks and credit unions, respectively, have the authority to issue rules and guidance that can preempt state laws. Their actions in this case appear to have been guided by a broader perspective on the national payment system and its interconnectedness.
The lawsuits filed by the retail groups are essentially an attempt to challenge the validity and scope of these federal regulations. By suing the OCC and NCUA directly in federal court, the retailers are seeking to have the court declare the federal rules unlawful or improperly applied, thereby clearing the path for the Illinois law to be enforced. This strategy shifts the focus from a state-versus-federal jurisdiction battle to a direct challenge of federal agency rulemaking.
Broader Implications and Future Outlook
The outcome of this ongoing legal saga has far-reaching implications beyond Illinois. Many other states have considered or enacted similar legislation aimed at regulating swipe fees. A victory for the retail groups in their federal lawsuits could embolden similar efforts nationwide, potentially leading to a significant reshaping of how credit card transactions are priced and regulated across the country. Conversely, if the federal regulators’ actions are upheld, it could set a precedent that limits the ability of individual states to regulate aspects of the national payment system.
The arguments before the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals regarding the initial injunction, and the new lawsuits filed in the District of Columbia, represent two parallel tracks of legal contention. The retail industry’s strategy appears to be a multi-pronged approach: to fight the federal regulatory rules while simultaneously appealing the existing injunction.
The continued legal wrangling underscores the complex interplay between state legislative power, federal regulatory authority, and the entrenched interests of major financial institutions and the retail sector. As Rob Karr noted, the delay in resolving these issues means that "swipe fees continue to cost retailers and therefore consumers." The eventual resolution will likely hinge on judicial interpretation of federal banking laws, the scope of regulatory authority, and the courts’ assessment of the economic impacts on both businesses and consumers. The retail groups’ decision to sue the federal regulators directly signifies their determination to pursue every avenue to achieve their objective of reducing swipe fees, highlighting the significant economic stakes involved for millions of businesses and consumers across the nation.








