The landscape of the U.S. fix-and-flip real estate market has undergone a notable contraction during the third quarter of the year. A comprehensive survey conducted by Kiavi and John Burns Research and Consulting reveals a substantial decline in market conditions, primarily driven by persistently high mortgage rates exceeding 7%, which have effectively dampened buyer enthusiasm and demand. Concurrently, a confluence of falling home prices and escalating labor costs has severely eroded the profit margins for investors engaged in this sector, pushing the market to its lowest point in nearly four years.
The proprietary Burns + Kiavi Fix and Flip Market Index, a key indicator of market health, registered a reading of 53 in the third quarter. This figure represents a significant drop from the 59 recorded in the second quarter and a decrease from the 56 observed a year prior. The index, which gauges market conditions on a scale from 0 to 100, where readings below 50 signify contraction and above 50 indicate expansion, has not been this low since the fourth quarter of 2020. The findings are based on a quarterly survey encompassing approximately 280 active fix-and-flip investors, providing a granular view of the challenges and sentiments within this specialized segment of the real estate industry.
Mounting Headwinds: Higher Rates, Lower Prices, and Diminished Sales Expectations
The survey results paint a stark picture of declining investor confidence regarding future sales performance. Only 23% of fix-and-flip investors anticipate favorable sales conditions over the next six months, a figure that represents the lowest sentiment in four years. Conversely, a growing number, 19%, are bracing for poor sales, a proportion not seen since the fourth quarter of 2022, indicating a shift towards a more pessimistic outlook.
This market deceleration is not confined to any particular segment of investors; it is broadly impacting operators of all sizes. For the first time since the third quarter of 2022, larger-scale flippers—defined as those who have bought or sold at least eight homes within the preceding 18 months—reported experiencing more challenging market conditions than their smaller counterparts. This suggests that the cumulative effects of economic pressures are disproportionately affecting those with higher operational volumes and potentially greater exposure to market fluctuations.
The significant increase in mortgage rates has undeniably curtailed the pricing power of investors. A substantial 40% of flippers reported that home sale prices in their respective markets had decreased compared to the previous year. In contrast, only 16% observed price increases, while a considerable 36% indicated that prices remained largely stable. This widespread decline in sale prices directly translates to reduced potential returns for investors who rely on selling renovated properties at a profit.
Geographically, the impact of falling prices is most acutely felt in certain regions. The Southwest region reported the highest percentage of flippers experiencing price declines, with 67% indicating this trend. Southern California followed closely, with 50% of investors there reporting lower sale prices. In Texas and the Southeast, 47% of flippers encountered declining prices, and in Florida, 44% shared similar observations. These regional variations underscore the localized nature of real estate market dynamics, even within a national downturn.
Adding to the financial strain, approximately one in five flippers indicated that they were selling homes at prices below their initial "after-repair value" (ARV) estimates. This metric is crucial for investors as it represents the projected value of a property after renovations. Selling below this estimated value signifies a direct hit to profitability and suggests that initial renovation budgets and sales price projections may have been overly optimistic in the current environment. This situation is approaching the highest level of underperformance recorded by the survey since 2021, highlighting a persistent challenge in achieving projected returns.
Labor Pains: Immigration Enforcement and Rising Renovation Costs
Beyond the direct impact of interest rates and sales prices, the fix-and-flip market is also grappling with an increasingly challenging labor environment, with a notable contributing factor being intensified immigration enforcement. The survey revealed that 41% of flippers believe that increased immigration enforcement has negatively affected their labor force. This figure represents an increase from 33% when this question was last posed in the second quarter of 2025, indicating a growing concern and impact.
Investors are reporting a multi-faceted set of labor-related issues: a scarcity of skilled workers, a rise in labor costs, and consequently, extended project timelines. These delays and increased expenses can significantly disrupt renovation schedules and further compress already tight profit margins. The impact appears to be particularly acute in states like Florida and across the Southeast, regions that have historically relied on a significant immigrant workforce for construction and renovation trades. However, challenges in securing labor and managing costs are not isolated to these areas, with flippers in other regions also voicing their concerns.
This labor shortage and cost escalation can be partly attributed to broader economic trends. With tighter immigration policies, the pool of available workers for physically demanding and often lower-wage jobs in construction and renovation can shrink. This reduced supply, coupled with consistent or growing demand for these services, naturally drives up wages and can lead to project delays as contractors struggle to find and retain qualified personnel. The ripple effect of these labor constraints can be substantial, affecting not only individual flip projects but also the overall pace of housing market activity.
A Silver Lining: Increased Inventory Creates Acquisition Opportunities
Despite the prevailing headwinds, a glimmer of opportunity exists for fix-and-flip investors in the form of increased housing inventory. The survey indicates that more available homes are creating additional avenues for investors to acquire properties. Specifically, 24% of flippers reported that competition for deals was lower than what they typically experience. This represents the highest share in the survey’s history, suggesting that the market is becoming less crowded with eager buyers, allowing for more strategic acquisitions.
However, this increased availability has not translated into investors being willing to overpay. Investors remain cautious about their acquisition prices, demonstrating a prudent approach to capital deployment. The average flipper is now targeting a maximum purchase price equivalent to 67% of a property’s estimated after-repair value. This figure is a slight decrease from the previous quarter, indicating that investors are actively factoring in the current market uncertainties and potential for further price adjustments when making their offers.
Renovation costs, while a source of pressure, also exhibit considerable regional disparities. The national average cost incurred per flipped home stood at $72,000 during the third quarter. However, this average masks significant variations. In high-cost areas like Southern California, renovation expenses surged to an average of $133,000 per flipped home. The Northeast also experienced elevated costs, averaging $86,000. Conversely, regions like the Southeast and Texas reported comparatively lower renovation expenses, with averages of $47,000 and $46,000, respectively. These cost differences can significantly influence the profitability of a flip, making location a critical factor in an investor’s strategy.
Expert Recommendations for Navigating a Challenging Market
The findings from the Burns + Kiavi survey collectively highlight the persistent pressures facing fix-and-flip investors. The combination of elevated financing costs, a softening in buyer demand, and ongoing labor market constraints creates a complex economic environment for project execution and profitability.
In light of these challenges, John Burns, a recognized authority in real estate consulting, has offered strategic advice for investors aiming to navigate the current market. He strongly recommends that flippers maintain a high degree of discipline when acquiring properties. This includes meticulously evaluating potential deals and ensuring that sufficient profit margins are built into their projections. These margins are essential to absorb potential downward adjustments in sale prices and to mitigate the impact of unforeseen increases in labor expenses.
Furthermore, Burns advised lenders within the real estate ecosystem to adapt their underwriting practices. He suggests that lenders should prioritize evaluating properties based on their anticipated sale prices at the time of disposition, rather than solely relying on recently closed comparable sales. In a declining market, recent sales data can often lag behind current market realities, potentially leading to an overvaluation of a property. By focusing on projected sale prices, lenders can provide more accurate financing and help investors manage risk more effectively. This forward-looking approach is critical for maintaining stability and fostering responsible lending in a volatile market.
The ongoing analysis by Kiavi and John Burns Research and Consulting will be crucial for tracking the evolution of the fix-and-flip market and providing valuable insights to investors, lenders, and policymakers as the real estate landscape continues to shift. The data suggests a period of recalibration, where strategic planning, careful cost management, and a realistic assessment of market conditions will be paramount for success.









